Stotfold's first appearance in the FA Trophy ended at the first stage - but only after a narrow loss away to Redbridge.
The Eagles were beaten 1-0 courtesy of a thunderbolt from Joseph Elliott on 20 minutes, the left-back getting high up the pitch, cutting inside and then letting fly beyond the helpless Liam Gooch.
But the visitors had chances of their own with Henry Snee, Lewis Franklin and Kade Bagge all denied one way or another.
Redbridge did hit the post in added time as Stotfold committed men forward but the one goal proved enough.
Brett Donnolly's men are back in Southern League Division One Central action on Saturday when they go to AFC Dunstable.
Kye Tearle of Hitchin Town celebrates his goal against Redditch United. Picture: PETER ELSE (Image: Peter Else)
Hitchin Town played two Premier Division Central matches with the first, on Saturday, ending in a 2-2 draw at home to Redditch United.
They had gone behind to a Ciaren Jones own-goal on 29 minutes but by half-time were in front, Diogo Freitas-Gouveia and Kye Tearle the men on target.
However, a strike two minutes into the second half from the visitors earned them a point.
Hitchin Town celebrate as they beat Nuneaton Borough 3-0 at Top Field. Picture: PETER ELSE (Image: Peter Else)
Monday night's game brought Nuneaton Borough to Top Field but they were no match for the inspired hosts who ran away to a 3-0 success.
All three goals came in the second half with Stan Georgiou and Finley Wilkinson scoring in the opening 10 minutes.
Daniel Idiakhoa wrapped things up seven minutes from the end of the 90.
Bentley Assiedou (left) celebrates scoring four goals for Hitchin Town in the FA Youth Cup. Picture: PETER ELSE (Image: Peter Else)
The Canaries' U18 side came through a thrilling FA Youth Cup tie against Royston Town - winning 5-3 at home.
They took the lead through skipper Bentley Assiedou on 10 minutes but Royston then hit back with two quick goals of their own.
By half-time though Hitchin were back in front.
Assiedou converted a penalty after he was fouled in the box and then Gassem Benelghazi connected at the back post to a Henry Silver corner.
The Crows equalised again after both sides had created numerous chances but a second penalty gave the young Canaries the lead, and Assiedou a hat-trick.
He then cracked his fourth of the contest in stoppage time to send Hitchin into a first qualifying round game at Kempston Rovers.
There was a nine-goal thriller in the Spartan South Midlands League Premier Division as Baldock Town beat Crawley Green 6-3.
Brandon Carney, Owen Robertson and Dempsey Thomas all scored in the opening eight minutes and Jude White, Kit Brown and Troy Tizard-Cleghorn chipped in with the others.
Arlesey Town, however, fell to a 1-0 loss at St Panteleimon.
In Division One, Letchworth Eagles got their first success of the season, winning 2-0 at home to Buckingham.
Max Smith and Rory Gilham got the goals as Buckingham finished with 10 men.
Comments: Our rules
We want our comments to be a lively and valuable part of our community - a place where readers can debate and engage with the most important local issues. The ability to comment on our stories is a privilege, not a right, however, and that privilege may be withdrawn if it is abused or misused.
Please report any comments that break our rules.
Read the rules here